MadMummy76
FPS Junkie
- Joined
- Aug 20, 2020
- Messages
- 3,891
- Points
- 113
I know everyone was waiting for this so here goes: /s
Again, this is not necessarily a direct comparison but a judgement based on expectation and value provided by the boards. I feel a few lines of explanation is necessary for some of the choices might seem odd to some.
GIGABYTE X58: I purchased this when I first had the opportunity to build my PC without heavy compromises. It was as bad as it was expensive. I contemplated banishing it to the garbage tier, but I showed mercy. So why is it so bad? It was unstable at the mildest overclocks, I couldn't even get the expensive RAM I got to run anywhere near its rated speed with it. Huge disappointment. I vowed to never buy GIGABYTE again for my main rig after this.
ASROCK 775 Dual-VSTA: This did exactly what I wanted it to do. Be a bridge platform while I upgraded my GPU from AGP to PCIE, and my RAM from DDR to DDR2 bit by bit. It worked flawlessly with all combinations I had thrown at it. Without it I'd have needed to replace everything in my PC at once. Which would've meant some ungodly compromises.
ECS K7S5A: Everybody thinks of ECS as a garbage brand, probably rightly so. But this was the only board I ever owned from this brand, and it worked perfectly for me. I had a shoestring budget to build at this time, so I decided I'd rather spend it on the CPU. I did not experience any drawbacks. I was even able to OC with a modified BIOS, which was an added bonus I never expected.
Also anything older than the P2L97, I really have no opinion on, before the SLOT1 era all I knew about hardware is how to turn it on.
Again, this is not necessarily a direct comparison but a judgement based on expectation and value provided by the boards. I feel a few lines of explanation is necessary for some of the choices might seem odd to some.
GIGABYTE X58: I purchased this when I first had the opportunity to build my PC without heavy compromises. It was as bad as it was expensive. I contemplated banishing it to the garbage tier, but I showed mercy. So why is it so bad? It was unstable at the mildest overclocks, I couldn't even get the expensive RAM I got to run anywhere near its rated speed with it. Huge disappointment. I vowed to never buy GIGABYTE again for my main rig after this.
ASROCK 775 Dual-VSTA: This did exactly what I wanted it to do. Be a bridge platform while I upgraded my GPU from AGP to PCIE, and my RAM from DDR to DDR2 bit by bit. It worked flawlessly with all combinations I had thrown at it. Without it I'd have needed to replace everything in my PC at once. Which would've meant some ungodly compromises.
ECS K7S5A: Everybody thinks of ECS as a garbage brand, probably rightly so. But this was the only board I ever owned from this brand, and it worked perfectly for me. I had a shoestring budget to build at this time, so I decided I'd rather spend it on the CPU. I did not experience any drawbacks. I was even able to OC with a modified BIOS, which was an added bonus I never expected.
Also anything older than the P2L97, I really have no opinion on, before the SLOT1 era all I knew about hardware is how to turn it on.