I'm on board with efficiency vs performance cores - I don't have an issue with a split setup at all. I'm all for an efficient setup when I'm not using it, or using it only lightly, but yeah, when I need the performance I want it there without having to hassle with it. I would ~love~ it if my desktop could ramp all the way down to no fans at all and be totally silent if it's idle or lightly used, but throttle up to the same performance I have now. I'm sure I could probably do that now with very careful component selection, but it's not "standard" and you have to build around that idea with very specific parts throughout.
But it doesn't work unless it's seamless - the scheduler and programs need to be smart enough to know when and where they should be running. If that part doesn't work, you may as well have a slow computer and a fast computer and just use whichever you need at the time.
It works very very well on my MBP - but that's a case where the hardware and software are pretty intertwined. I love getting almost a week out of a battery charge, absolutely no fan noise (or rotating parts period for that matter), and it ramps up when I need performance without me having to do anything special.