Thanks for the feedback. I played it with a mouse and keyboard because that's what I'm used to, but had a nagging feeling that many parts of the game were better suited to a controller, and was interested in hearing from those who had tried both.
In my opinion, the combat system in TW3 is not well polished, and its weakness is especially apparent when facing groups of enemies. That's not to say it can't be fun at times, though.
I haven't tried the next-gen update yet, but I spent a lot of time with the game years ago. At some point I'll get to it. The game has such beautiful music.
A moment ago I got distracted looking at GOG's winter sale. I'm tempted by Horizon Zero Dawn, but worried about performance. My system technically exceeds GOG's recommended specs, but that doesn't fill me with confidence. The PC my games are on is in need of a major OS update and configuration, which I dread. And I'm really pissed off at Google right now — an equally irrelevant piece of information.