I rode the wave with Hardocp not as a worker but a reader. From back in the early Celeron candy bar CPU's up to what was current when they shut down a few years ago now.
They did have great reviews. And were always unafraid of expressing any opinions they had in them which is good. Makes me wonder why it all shut down, never had visibility into the back end.
While I did briefly work as a news poster on the [H] as Tsing can corroborate, Kyle wasn't one to talk about his personal stuff much.
I suspect it was a combination of:
1.) User preferences video and the existence of adblockers driving ad money more and more to YouTube, making it increasingly difficult to make ends meet in the written format. He was working on starting a VR Based Youtube channel for a while (which I can't seem to find on Yotube right now), but that apparently didn't go anywhere.
I did find this from AMD's Capsaicin & Cream event from 2017 though in which he was about to launch it:
When you are used to producing written content, it's tough to compete with the polish of the likes of Linus' pretty face, even through your content is of higher quality and more hard hitting. The kids today expect a Youtube TV show, and I suspect that just didn't mesh well with Kyle's more serious IDGAF style.
The formula now is goofy, lighthearted pretty faces, taking payola for industry while influencing the market for them. That was the antithesis of Kyle's approach.
Toms Hardware had been out of the game for a long time, with Dr. Tom Pabst selling the site - what - 17 years ago now? But then Anandtech sold itself to the same company that owned TomsHardware with Anand Lal Shimpi taking a job at Apple. Kyle probably saw the same things in the cards they did, and decided it was time to change chapters.
Not quite sure how this site makes it work, but I suspect it might partly have to do with differing expectations of what the site and the business is, and what it isn't. HardOCP was Kyle's full time gig, and he put everything into it. Not sure if that is the same here.
2.) Intel just came in and made him an offer that was difficult to refuse. With the future in websiite written reviews not looking as promising as the past he probably figured it was his responsibility to his family to move on.
Kyle discusses some of the changes to the review industry in
his Blog post from last January which make for a kind of depressing reinforcement of my beliefs of where the industry is going. :/